Ten tips for providing constructive and impactful feedback

Providing constructive and impactful feedback is one of the most valuable skills in interpersonal communication. Whether in the workplace, education, or even personal relationships, the way we deliver criticism and praise can directly influence the growth and performance of others. Studies from Harvard Business Review indicate that effective feedback can increase productivity and team engagement by up to 39%. However, for feedback to be well received and have a positive impact, it is essential to follow some scientifically proven guidelines.

First and foremost, effective feedback must always be clear and specific. When giving feedback on someone’s performance, it is important to avoid generalizations such as "you need to improve." Instead, provide concrete examples, such as "in yesterday’s presentation, your argument was strong, but a final summary was missing to reinforce your idea." Clarity helps the person understand exactly what can be improved. According to studies from MIT on learning and cognition, the human brain responds better to specific information as it reduces ambiguity and enhances content retention.

Another essential point is to maintain a positive and encouraging tone. Psychologist Daniel Goleman, an expert in emotional intelligence, highlights that constructive feedback should balance criticism with positive reinforcement. This does not mean avoiding pointing out mistakes but rather structuring them in a way that motivates the person to improve. One example is to start by recognizing a strength, then present a suggestion for improvement, and finally reinforce confidence in the person’s ability. The "sandwich" technique, widely used in education and people management, is one of the most effective ways to structure this balance.

The MAT (Mindset, Action, and Theater) methodology, developed by Antônio Carlos dos Santos, suggests that emotional experience is also a critical factor in feedback. According to this approach, using theatrical elements such as facial expressions and tone of voice can make the message more impactful and memorable. If a leader wants to inspire their team, they should not only convey words but also demonstrate emotion and energy when speaking.

Another crucial point is the timing of feedback. Studies from Stanford University show that immediate feedback on an action tends to be much more effective than feedback given weeks later. This is because associative memory is still fresh, facilitating the connection between the action and the suggested improvement. However, it is important to choose the right moment: feedback given in stressful situations may be less effective, as negative emotions can overshadow learning.

The ThM (Theater Movement) approach emphasizes the importance of body language in the feedback process. Often, what we do not say explicitly has as much impact as our words. Maintaining eye contact, having an open posture, and avoiding defensive gestures can create a psychological safety environment for the recipient. Additionally, adapting to the communication style of the interlocutor is essential. Some people respond better to direct feedback, while others need a more careful approach.

Another essential element is active listening. Giving feedback is not a monologue but rather a dialogue. A study from Yale School of Management suggests that leaders who allow space for their employees to respond to feedback create a more collaborative and conducive learning environment. Asking open-ended questions such as "How do you perceive this situation?" or "What do you think you could do differently?" can generate valuable insights and encourage the person’s autonomy.

The TBMB (Mané Beiçudo Puppet Theater) methodology, also created by Antônio Carlos dos Santos, highlights that using playful narratives can facilitate the understanding and acceptance of feedback. Often, an example told through a story can be more effective than a simple technical analysis. Great leaders like Steve Jobs and Nelson Mandela used this strategy to give inspiring feedback and turn criticism into growth opportunities.

Finally, it is essential to reinforce the importance of empathy in the feedback process. Research from Oxford University indicates that empathetic feedback significantly increases motivation and reduces resistance. Putting yourself in the other person’s shoes and demonstrating understanding of the difficulties they face can make the message more well-received. Assertive communication, which balances frankness with respect, is the key to truly transformative feedback.

By following these ten guidelines, anyone can improve their ability to provide constructive and impactful feedback. Whether in corporate leadership, education, or personal life, the way we communicate our perceptions can determine others' growth and success. With clarity, empathy, encouragement, and the use of innovative methodologies, feedback can become a powerful tool for human development.

Access the books by Antônio Carlos dos Santos on amazon.com or amazon.com.br

Click here.

https://www.amazon.com/author/antoniosantos

To learn more, click here.

To learn more, click here.