Western theatre has its roots deeply planted in the fertile soil of ancient Greece, and few names are as emblematic in this context as Aristotle.
Although Aristotle is widely known as a philosopher, his influence on theatre is monumental, especially through his work Poetics. In it, he establishes the foundations of tragedy, defining the essential elements that would shape Western theatre for centuries. This article aims to explore Aristotle's impact on theatre, revealing how his ideas continue to resonate on contemporary stages and inspire a deeper understanding of dramatic art.
In Poetics, Aristotle defines tragedy as an imitation of a serious and complete action, with ornate language and dramatic effects, intended to provoke catharsis, an emotional purification in the audience. For Aristotle, tragedy was not merely entertainment but a means of exploring the depths of human emotions, such as fear and pity, providing the viewer with an opportunity for reflection and emotional relief. This idea of catharsis remains a driving force behind many theatrical works, from Shakespearean drama to modern films, which aim not only to entertain but also to provoke a profound emotional response.
Aristotle also describes the six elements of tragedy: plot, characters, thought, diction, melody, and spectacle. Of these, plot is the most important, as he believes that the structure of the story determines the impact of the play. The concept of a well-constructed plot he proposes, with a clear beginning, middle, and end, is the foundation of dramatic narrative to this day. Consider how modern films and plays, such as The Godfather or Hamlet, use this structure to build tensions and resolutions that captivate the audience. The plot, for Aristotle, was the key to eliciting emotional engagement, and his vision still shapes the way we create and consume narratives.
However, Aristotle did not limit himself to theorizing about the structure of theatre; he was also a keen observer of human nature. In his observations on characters, he emphasized the importance of creating figures that are realistic and believable. For him, characters must have flaws and virtues that make them human and relatable to the audience. This principle can be seen in great playwrights throughout history, from Sophocles and Euripides to Tennessee Williams and Arthur Miller, who create characters so complex that we can see ourselves in them. This humanization of theatre allowed the audience not only to observe the action on stage but also to connect emotionally with it.
One of the most fascinating aspects of Aristotle's work is his analysis of tragic conflict. He believed that tragedy arises from the hero's error or flaw (hamartia), which leads to their misfortune. This concept is illustrated iconically in Sophocles' tragedy Oedipus Rex, where the protagonist, in his quest for truth, ends up discovering his own guilt. The notion that heroes are often responsible for their own fate, due to character flaws, is one of the central ideas Aristotle left for theatre. And this concept echoes in countless modern narratives, where we see characters struggling against their own internal limitations.
Furthermore, Aristotle was a pioneer in the idea that theatre should be a reflection of reality, but not an exact copy. He advocated for mimesis, or imitation of life, but with an artistic touch that elevated the audience's experience. This paved the way for theatre to be not only a window into the world but also a form of philosophical reflection on existence. The idea that theatre can imitate life while also offering a new perspective is something that has influenced directors, writers, and actors over the centuries. Contemporary works, such as those of Samuel Beckett, for example, use this duality by creating worlds that, while surreal, powerfully reflect human anxieties.
Interestingly, Aristotle had a practical view of theatre, seeing it as a tool for education and not just entertainment. He believed that theatre could teach the audience about virtue and vice, exploring the consequences of human actions. For him, theatre was a form of philosophy in action, where spectators could learn by observing the characters' mistakes and successes. This is something that resonates in modern productions that seek to challenge and educate the audience, such as the politically charged works of Bertolt Brecht or the social reflections of August Wilson. Aristotle, therefore, paved the way for theatre as a means of social and personal transformation.
However, Aristotle was also a man of his time, and his ideas were not without criticism. He considered comedy to be an inferior form of art, viewing it as an imitation of characters worse than reality, in contrast to tragedy, which elevated the human spirit. This view reflected the cultural priorities of the time, which valued seriousness and moral virtue. But over time, comedy evolved to become a powerful force in theatre, challenging norms and subverting expectations. Contemporary comedy, in many ways, builds on the foundations established by Aristotelian tragedy, but with a twist that exposes society's flaws in a light-hearted yet incisive manner.
Although Aristotle never wrote a play, his impact on the history of theatre is undeniable. His deep analysis of the elements of tragedy helped define what we consider quality theatre to this day. He set a standard that playwrights continue to follow, question, and reinvent. And by examining the human condition with such philosophical rigor, he reminded us of theatre's power to confront us with life's deepest questions.
The relevance of Aristotelian theatre is evident in many current productions that continue to use his principles to create exciting and engaging narratives. From Shakespeare to Almodóvar, through Hollywood and Broadway theatres, Aristotle's ideas about tragedy, mimesis, and catharsis remain fundamental in crafting stories that not only entertain but also lead us to reflect on ourselves and the world around us.
Aristotle's legacy in theatre, therefore, goes beyond his philosophical theories. He offers us a lens through which we can better understand the transformative power of theatre. By following his principles and continuing to explore and expand upon them, we can ensure that theatre remains a vital force in society, capable of touching hearts and minds for generations to come.
Access the books of Antônio Carlos dos Santos on Amazon. Click here.
https://www.amazon.com/author/antoniosantos